Books Like The Honey Witch
Readers fell head over heels for this cozy cottagecore romantasy, where honey-and-bees magic feels as real as the herbs in your cupboard and a grumpy/sunshine sapphic romance unfolds at the most satisfying slow burn. The "no one can love the Honey Witch" curse creates the perfect romantic tension, while the island-cottage setting wraps you in escapist warmth. Apothecary work, nature-rooted spellcraft, and a threat that builds just when you need it keep the gentle, dreamy vibes fresh and full of momentum.
The Go-To Read
Curses & Cold Brew
by Ali K. Mulford and K. Elle Morrison
- Flirty apothecary witch × grumpy demon = forbidden sapphic slowburn perfection
- Herbcraft & village coziness mirror Lottie's cottage-core apothecary vibes ✨
- Demonic curse-mark adds same high-concept yearning obstacle you loved
- Sunshine believer slowly melts cynical grump through tender late-night moments
Buy on Amazon
The Under-the-Radar Pick
Doughnuts and Doom
by Balazs Lorinczi
- Accidental curse forces witch & grumpy guitarist into close proximity 🎸✨
- Hands-on potion-mixing gives major cottagecore craft vibes you crave
- Skeptic vs believer banter slowly melts into soft sapphic yearning
- Small-town donut runs & cozy workspaces = warm queer-positive feels
Buy on Amazon
The Wildcard Pick
This Spells Disaster
by Tori Anne Martin
- Potion-maker accidentally love-potions grumpy spellcaster → fake dating & panic
- Warm chaotic sunshine vs guarded rule-follower = chef's kiss dynamic
- Forbidden magic = curse-level obstacle powering that sapphic slow burn
- Apothecary craft scenes + festival forced proximity = cozy cottagecore vibes
Buy on Amazon
The Go-To Read
Witching Hour at Maple Hollow
by Riley Loren
- F/F grumpy/sunshine slow burn w/ a curse only love breaks
- Tactile herbal witchcraft & foraged teas = Honey Witch vibes
- Every touch risks triggering the curse—stakes stay SO high
- Cozy New England hamlet & hearth magic = cottagecore escapism
Buy on Amazon
The Under-the-Radar Pick
Cursed
by Elizabeth Jeannel
- Sapphic slow burn where loving = death, every touch risks fate
- Grumpy witch meets 500-yr-old sunshine in cozy small-town magic
- Kitchen-table spellwork & diner vibes give cottagecore-adjacent comfort
- High-stakes curse forces them to outsmart destiny for their HEA
Buy on Amazon
The Go-To Read
Sweet and Bitter Magic
by Adrienne Tooley
- Cursed witch & secret Source team up to fight blight—forbidden f/f romance
- Foraging, steeping teas, blending salves = pure cottagecore apothecary vibes ✨
- Grumpy/sunshine dynamic: brittle skeptic meets warm, caretaking magic believer
- Small village, cozy woods—every spell feels like kitchen-table witchcraft
Buy on Amazon
The Under-the-Radar Pick
Starlit Coven
by Coral Lawson
- Midnight orchard rites & mortar-and-pestle tinctures = tactile cozy magic ✨
- Honey-infused ciders & lanternlit bees echo The Honey Witch's apothecary vibes
- Jarred preserves brewed as charms bring that same domestic witchcraft energy
- Small-kitchen spellwork feels enchanting yet wonderfully within reach 🍯
Buy on Amazon
The Go-To Read
Tea Leaves and Truth Spells
by Thea Harlow
- Sapphic slow burn in a cozy seaside cove = island vibes ✨
- Tea-witch MC brews truth spells in her tiny apothecary shop
- Grumpy sailor x sunshine believer romance w/ forced confessions twist
- Same cottagecore retreat energy: herbs, hearth & close-knit community
Buy on Amazon
The Go-To Read
Mooncakes
by Suzanne Walker and Wendy Xu
- Sapphic witch x werewolf w/ forest curse = cottagecore vibes
- Nova learns spells from grandma mentors through foraging & sigils
- Grumpy/sunshine slowburn as magic skills unlock Tam's safety
- Cozy apothecary lessons + demonic threat balance gentle & stakes
Buy on Amazon
NextBookAfter participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. The site earns from qualifying purchases made through affiliate links.