NextBookAfter Fake Dating, Swoon-Worthy Athletes & Sizzling Campus Romance

Books Like The Deal

Curated by NextBookAfter Editors

Every match is selected around tone, themes, pacing, character dynamics, and emotional payoff. Read the recommendation methodology.

The Deal captured hearts as the addictive college romance that introduced countless readers to hockey romance—pairing a confident hockey captain with a determined music student in a fake dating arrangement that sparkles with witty banter and slow-burn tension. What made it irresistible was Elle Kennedy's perfect blend of humor, heart, and sizzling chemistry, all wrapped up in binge-worthy campus escapism that kept you turning pages long past bedtime. It's the book that launched the beloved Off-Campus series and became a gateway for readers discovering just how swoon-worthy hockey players can be.

If you liked The Deal by Elle Kennedy, start here: these 3 recommendations aim for the same reading payoff without repeating the exact same book.

Books With More

Fake Dating That Feels Real

You loved watching Garrett and Hannah's tutoring-for-dating deal spark something neither saw coming—that delicious slow burn from business arrangement to butterflies and breathless moments. You'll find that same irresistible progression here: bargains that start as convenience and blossom into the kind of connection that makes you forget they were ever pretending.

The Go-To Read
Boyfriend Bargain cover

Boyfriend Bargain

by Ilsa Madden-Mills

  • Cash-strapped college girl + hockey star = paid fake-dating deal
  • Campus parties & team events turn pretend into real feelings
  • Tutoring-for-dating vibes but w/ financial stakes & slow burn
  • Transactional contract → actual butterflies, no rushed confessions
Buy on Amazon
The Under-the-Radar Pick
I Can Be The One cover

I Can Be The One

by Ellie Blackbourne

  • Tuition-stakes fake dating w/ brother's hockey teammate = delicious forbidden tension
  • Staged intimacy & daily proximity blur the lines into real feelings
  • Quiet longing meets slow-burn chemistry that sneaks up on you
  • Campus parties + pretend couple moments = peak 'oops we're in love'
Buy on Amazon
The Wildcard Pick
The Bet cover

The Bet

by Kelcie James

  • Hockey player + virgin athlete strike a fake dating deal
  • Constant proximity at team parties = rules start blurring fast
  • Staged affection turns into actual butterflies & emotional intimacy
  • That 'oops we caught feelings' progression without rushed confessions
Buy on Amazon

FAQ: What to Read After The Deal

What should I read if I liked The Deal?
If you liked The Deal by Elle Kennedy, NextBookAfter recommends Boyfriend Bargain, I Can Be The One, The Bet and other adjacent reads chosen for overlapping appeal rather than surface-level similarity.
Are these recommendations only for fans of The Deal?
No. They are strongest for readers who liked The Deal by Elle Kennedy, but they also work for readers chasing similar tone, themes, or narrative energy.
How many books like The Deal are on this page?
This page currently highlights 3 books for readers who want to know what to read after The Deal.

NextBookAfter participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. The site earns from qualifying purchases made through affiliate links.