NextBookAfter
Get book recommendations that actually understand why you liked something. Built for readers who know why a book worked.
Join the waitlist
The Wrong Carlos Cover
★★★★☆ 4.24 • Goodreads

Genre

  • True Crime

Subgenres

  • Wrongful Conviction
  • Criminal Justice
  • Death Penalty

Tags

  • Investigative Reporting
  • Institutional Failure
  • Mistaken Identity
  • Death Row
  • Police Misconduct
  • Prosecutorial Misconduct
  • Human Cost
  • Legal Injustice

If Catch the Devil by Pamela Colloff left you raging at death-row urgency and institutional failure, read The Wrong Carlos by James S. Liebman and the Columbia DeLuna Project next.

Curated by NextBookAfter Editors. This read-alike match weighs tone, themes, pacing, character dynamics, and emotional payoff rather than genre alone. See how recommendations are chosen.

Buy on Amazon

Why It's Your Next Read

  • Death-row urgency drives every discovery
  • One mistaken identity becomes irreversible
  • Evidence accumulates with dreadful precision
  • Institutional failures widen the outrage
  • Victim and defendant both stay human

If Catch the Devil gripped you by showing how a useful liar could turn official incentives into lethal power, The Wrong Carlos follows the same widening path from one criminal case to a devastating institutional reckoning. A Columbia Law School team reconstructs the murder of Wanda Lopez and the conviction of Carlos DeLuna step by step, testing a nighttime eyewitness identification against police records, court transcripts, photographs, recordings, and witness interviews. The deeper the investigation goes, the harder it becomes to treat DeLuna's execution as one isolated mistake.

One wrongful execution becomes a map of every safeguard that failed.

The reporting is exhaustive without losing sight of the people who paid for every failed safeguard. Mistaken identification, inadequate representation, police inaction, and prosecutorial misconduct gather into the same progression from disbelief to anger that makes Colloff's investigation so difficult to put down—and so impossible to dismiss once the full pattern is visible.

The state called the other Carlos a phantom; the evidence makes the system's failure impossible to ignore.

Buy on Amazon

What Readers Are Saying

"This was a fascinating read." — Jenny, Goodreads

What Readers Are Saying

"This book should make you angry. It should make you think." — Paul, Goodreads

What Readers Are Saying

"If you're even remotely interested, you should read this book." — Courtney, Goodreads

Two more ways to follow the feeling

Go Deeper—or Sideways

Cover of The Cadaver King and the Country Dentist by Radley Balko and Tucker Carrington

Under the Radar

The Cadaver King and the Country Dentist

by Radley Balko and Tucker Carrington

Two Convictions, One Broken System

In rural Mississippi, Kennedy Brewer and Levon Brooks are wrongly convicted of the murders of two young girls while the real killer remains free; Balko and Carrington trace those convictions through the careers of medical examiner Steven Hayne and forensic dentist Michael West and the legal system that sustained their testimony.

  • Intertwined cases build cumulative pressure
  • Flawed forensics become official truth
  • Mississippi institutions protect useful experts
  • Human cost keeps outrage grounded
Buy this book
Cover of Yellowface by R. F. Kuang

Wildcard Pick

Yellowface

by R. F. Kuang

The Liar Controls the Story

After witnessing fellow novelist Athena Liu's sudden death, June Hayward takes Athena's unpublished manuscript, rewrites it, and publishes it as her own, then keeps manufacturing explanations as acclaim and scrutiny close in. Kuang frames the theft and its fallout as a satire of racism, ambition, and the publishing industry.

Why it’s a wildcard: A darkly comic publishing novel looks like a sharp turn away from Gulf Coast true crime, but it recreates Catch the Devil's most gripping reader posture: horrified intimacy with a socially adept liar who can rationalize each fresh betrayal, followed by mounting anger as useful gatekeepers help turn the lie into an institutionally protected success.

  • A gifted liar narrates herself
  • Each betrayal demands another excuse
  • Gatekeepers reward the useful fiction
  • Public scrutiny tightens the trap
Buy this book

What to read after Catch the Devil

Readers searching for adult books like or similar to Catch the Devil by Pamela Colloff usually want adult true crime with qualities like investigative reporting, institutional failure, mistaken identity, and death row.

If your search is specifically for books similar to Catch the Devil for adults, this match keeps the grown-up stakes, voice, and reader payoff central rather than drifting into younger or purely genre-adjacent suggestions.

If you like Catch the Devil and want to know what to read next, start with The Wrong Carlos. It is the closest NextBookAfter match for readers who want a book like Catch the Devil with the same core appeal.

The Wrong Carlos is a similar next read for fans of Catch the Devil by Pamela Colloff because it shares investigative reporting, institutional failure, mistaken identity, and death row while moving through wrongful conviction and criminal justice.

Books like or similar to Catch the Devil: quick answers

What should I read after Catch the Devil by Pamela Colloff?
Start with The Wrong Carlos. It is a close NextBookAfter match for readers who want adult true crime with a similar mood, pace, and emotional payoff. It is especially useful if you want investigative reporting, institutional failure, and mistaken identity.
If I like Catch the Devil, what should I read next?
Read The Wrong Carlos next if you want another adult true crime pick with overlapping tone, themes, pacing, and reader payoff.
What is a book like Catch the Devil for adults?
The Wrong Carlos is the closest adult readalike here because it preserves the core appeal readers usually want after Catch the Devil by Pamela Colloff.
What are good books similar to Catch the Devil by Pamela Colloff for adults?
For adult true crime readers, The Wrong Carlos is a strong book similar to Catch the Devil by Pamela Colloff because it keeps the same read-alike appeal while moving through wrongful conviction and criminal justice.
Is The Wrong Carlos similar to Catch the Devil by Pamela Colloff?
Yes. The Wrong Carlos is recommended here because it carries readers from Catch the Devil by Pamela Colloff into wrongful conviction and criminal justice while preserving the core read-alike appeal.
Why recommend The Wrong Carlos for fans of Catch the Devil by Pamela Colloff?
The recommendation is based on overlapping appeal signals: tone, themes, character dynamics, pacing, and the specific payoff readers look for after Catch the Devil by Pamela Colloff.

NextBookAfter participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. The site earns from qualifying purchases made through affiliate links.