Just finished A Good Girl's Guide to Murder? Next up read The Agathas…
You know how sometimes you finish a book and just crave that same rush of excitement, where a clever young woman takes charge and uncovers all those hidden truths? Well, if A Good Girl's Guide to Murder left you hooked on its blend of teen smarts and suspenseful sleuthing, The Agathas is going to feel like the perfect next read. It's got that familiar setup of high school girls diving into a mystery—a disappearance in their cozy coastal town—that keeps you guessing with every turn of the page.
"…Loved the teenage sleuths Alice and Iris, think Nancy Drew with a partner. A nice change of pace if you enjoy a YA murder mystery. …"— Holly B ( slowly catching up), Goodreads
The protagonists, Alice and Iris, are just like Pip in their determination and quick thinking, teaming up to piece together clues while dealing with everyday teen stuff like friendships and family drama. What makes this such a spot-on recommendation is how it captures that same appeal for readers who love a good puzzle mixed with heart. Published just a few years after Holly Jackson's hit, it taps into the same wave of YA thrillers that celebrate resourceful young women outsmarting the adults around them.
You'll get those satisfying twists and a sense of justice prevailing, all in a setting that feels relatable and fun—think small-town secrets with a dash of classic mystery flair. The book is packed with Agatha Christie Easter eggs that mystery lovers will appreciate, adding an extra layer of literary charm to the modern teen detective story.
"I also loved all the little moments and quotes from Agatha Christie novels. This felt like the authors wrote a love letter to her and if you enjoy Christie’s mysteries, I think you will get a kick out of this book."— Lex Kent, Goodreads
Why This Works So Well
It's not too scary or dark, just the right amount of thrill to keep you up late reading, and it's perfect for anyone who enjoys stories that make you cheer for the underdog. Best of all, this book builds on what fans adore about A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: the joy of watching smart girls win the day, with plenty of emotional depth and surprises along the way. Whether you're curling up on a rainy afternoon or sharing recommendations with friends, The Agathas delivers that cozy yet exciting vibe that leaves you feeling inspired and ready for more adventures.
